NHL · New York Islanders
Islanders 5, Blue Jackets 1: Schaefer’s first hat trick drives a third straight win
November 17, 2026 · Final
Matthew Schaefer scored his first NHL hat trick Tuesday as the Islanders beat Columbus 5-1 at UBS Arena. His second goal was the pivotal one: with the Blue Jackets back within a goal in the third period, Schaefer restored New York’s two-goal cushion at 7:01.
The Islanders reached 10-6-4, good for 24 points, with their third consecutive win. Schaefer scored on three of his nine shots and logged 23:23. Ilya Sorokin stopped 28 of 29 shots, while New York put 41 shots on the Columbus net.
A one-goal game becomes a decisive finish
Anthony Duclair opened the scoring on a power play at 19:02 of the first period, with assists from Mathew Barzal and Tony DeAngelo. Schaefer made it 2-0 at 1:34 of the second. Those goals were only 2:32 apart in elapsed playing time, straddling the intermission.
Zach Werenski gave Columbus a way back at 1:12 of the third. The score stayed 2-1 until Schaefer struck again 5:49 later. Ryan Pulock and Duclair received the assists on the goal, which survived a Columbus challenge for goaltender interference.
The official record also lists a two-minute bench penalty for the unsuccessful challenge. New York did not score on that power play. Its next goal came at 11:52, when DeAngelo finished a move set up by Barzal and Matias Maccelli, making the lead 4-1.
Schaefer completed the hat trick into an empty net at 16:08. The final three goals therefore came from two Islanders defensemen. Columbus had made the game competitive early in the third; New York answered with three consecutive goals over 9:07.
The defense supplies four goals
Schaefer’s three and DeAngelo’s one accounted for four of the Islanders’ five goals. DeAngelo added an assist, Duclair finished with a goal and an assist, and Barzal supplied two assists in his second game back after his season debut Saturday.
NHL.com identifies Schaefer as the third Islanders defenseman with a hat trick, the first since Denis Potvin in 1982. His goals built a 2-0 lead, restored a two-goal margin after Columbus scored, then finished the game into an empty net.
Sorokin’s 28 saves meant one Columbus goal was all the Islanders had to answer. Cam Talbot stopped 36 shots, with the empty-net goal accounting for the difference between his four goals against and New York’s five. The Islanders combined that goaltending with a 12-shot advantage and scoring from the back end.
Go to the sources
See something that needs attention? Read our corrections process.