STADIUM&STREET
Explore S&S

Yankees · Reported agreement

Tim Hill’s reported Yankees return preserves a useful escape option

November 15, 2026

Published Sources checked 2 min read

Updated

Tim Hill, reported Yankees agreement: one year, $2.25 million for 2027, with a $2.5 million club option for 2028. Not yet confirmed by the club. 2026 regular season: 33 of 35 inherited runners stranded, two scored; 67 appearances, 58 and two-thirds innings, 4.60 ERA. Contract: MLB.com. Statistics: MLB.
Original contract and inherited-runner card. Contract terms remain reported and unconfirmed by the Yankees; statistics are from MLB’s 2026 regular-season record.

November 17: Bednar accepts the qualifying offer

David Bednar accepted the Yankees’ one-year, $23.15 million qualifying offer Tuesday, according to MLB.com and Yahoo Sports. New York’s closer is returning for 2027. This resolves the pending Bednar decision described in the original November 15 report below. Hill’s separate agreement remains reported; the Yankees’ transaction register did not list his signing at this update.

Original November 15 report

Tim Hill allowed only two of the 35 runners he inherited to score in 2026. That is the clearest argument for keeping a reliever whose reported return would preserve a specific part of the Yankees’ bullpen: someone trusted to enter with trouble already on the bases.

MLB.com’s Bryan Hoch reported Sunday, citing information obtained by Mark Feinsand, that Hill has agreed to a one-year, $2.25 million contract with a $2.5 million club option for 2028. The Yankees have not confirmed the agreement. Their transaction register and Hill’s individual MLB transaction record did not list a completed signing at the noon check.

The runners already on base

Hill made 67 appearances and worked 58⅔ innings for New York during the 2026 regular season. His line included a 4.60 ERA, a 1.14 WHIP, 25 strikeouts and 13 walks. MLB.com reports that his 68.9% ground-ball rate led major-league relievers. His low strikeout total makes the shape and placement of the contact he allows especially consequential.

The inherited-runner record adds information that ERA alone cannot supply. Those runners are generally charged to the pitcher who put them on base. Hill stranded 33 of 35, or 94.3%, while his own earned-run total was 30. The two measures describe different parts of the same job: what happened to runners already aboard and what happened to runners charged to him.

That distinction also sets the limit on the case for him. Thirty-five inherited runners are one season’s opportunities, and stranding 33 does not guarantee the same result next year. Hill also allowed 12 home runs. The Yankees would be retaining a pitcher with a useful contact-based role and a strong escape record, while accepting that balls put in play and mistakes left in the air can change outcomes quickly.

One role, with more bullpen work ahead

The reported option would give the club a separate decision for 2028; it is not a second guaranteed season established by this report. At the reported 2027 salary, retaining Hill would preserve one familiar role while the Yankees address the rest of the relief staff.

Hoch reports that closer David Bednar is considering a $23.15 million qualifying offer, with a decision due Tuesday, November 17. That remains unresolved. Hill’s reported agreement would give New York some continuity, but the shape of the late innings still depends on decisions involving other pitchers.

Go to the sources

See something that needs attention? Read our corrections process.

All MLB stories ↗