STADIUM&STREET
Explore S&S

MLB · Hall of Fame ballot

Posey arrives on the Hall ballot as Pettitte’s window narrows

November 16, 2026

Published Sources checked 3 min read
2027 Hall of Fame writers’ ballot: 27 candidates, 14 new and 13 returning. Selected returning candidates’ 2026 vote shares: Chase Utley 59.1%, Andy Pettitte 48.5%, Félix Hernández 46.1%, David Wright 14.8%. Election threshold 75%. Pettitte enters year nine of ten. These are prior results, not 2027 forecasts. Results January 19, 2027, 6 p.m. EST.
Original chart of selected holdovers’ 2026 vote shares, with the 75% election threshold. Source: MLB.com’s November 16 ballot report; dates and rules from the Hall of Fame. These bars do not show votes in the new election.

Buster Posey joins the Baseball Writers’ Association of America Hall of Fame ballot with three World Series championships and a National League MVP award. Andy Pettitte returns with only two writers’ elections left. The 27-player ballot announced Monday puts a prominent new candidate alongside several holdovers still well short of election.

There are 14 first-time candidates and 13 returning players. Results will be announced January 19, 2027, at 6 p.m. Eastern on MLB Network. Election requires support on at least 75% of the ballots cast.

A strong first case, a shorter runway

Posey’s case combines peak performance with a demanding defensive position. The Hall credits him with seven All-Star selections, five Silver Sluggers, a Gold Glove and a .302 career average over 12 seasons, all with San Francisco. He won Rookie of the Year in 2010 and MVP in 2012, two of the Giants’ three championship seasons during his career.

His 1,500 career hits make the length of that career part of the discussion. The case for him rests on elite catching and offensive quality: a .302 hitter who won the league’s MVP award while carrying the defensive workload behind the plate.

Jon Lester brings a different record: 200 wins, a 3.66 ERA over 16 seasons and three World Series championships. Other newcomers include Jake Arrieta, Brett Gardner, Andrew Miller and Pablo Sandoval.

What New York’s candidates face

Pettitte received 48.5% in the 2026 election after a 20.6-percentage-point increase, according to MLB.com’s ballot report. He needs another 26.5 points to reach 75% and enters his ninth year of a maximum ten. Another increase of the same size would leave him at 69.1%. His recent momentum is substantial; its repetition alone would still fall short.

David Wright returns for his fourth year after receiving 14.8%. Alex Rodriguez enters year six at 40.0%, while Gardner appears for the first time after spending his entire 14-year career with the Yankees. Chase Utley leads all returning candidates at 59.1%; Félix Hernández follows Pettitte at 46.1%. These are last election’s shares, not forecasts of the next result.

The ballot and the dates

The complete first-time group is Jake Arrieta, Jay Bruce, Asdrúbal Cabrera, Starlin Castro, Wade Davis, Brett Gardner, Jon Lester, Andrew Miller, Buster Posey, Pablo Sandoval, Ervin Santana, Kyle Seager, Joakim Soria and Ryan Zimmerman.

Returning candidates are Bobby Abreu, Mark Buehrle, Cole Hamels, Félix Hernández, Torii Hunter, Dustin Pedroia, Andy Pettitte, Alex Rodriguez, Francisco Rodríguez, Jimmy Rollins, Chase Utley, Omar Vizquel and David Wright. Vizquel is in his tenth and final year. Players must receive at least 5% to remain eligible for the next writers’ ballot, subject to the ten-year limit.

Ballots must carry a December 31 postmark. This players’ election is separate from the Contemporary Baseball Era Committee’s December 6 vote on managers and executives. The two routes will help form the same Class of 2027, with induction scheduled for July 25 in Cooperstown.

Go to the sources

See something that needs attention? Read our corrections process.

All MLB stories ↗